In Ruins: A Dungeon Building Game by M. Allen Hall: A Game Review 


I recently had the opportunity to play In Ruins: A Dungeon Building Game. My Tuesday night gaming group had a blast. If you’ve ever played any sort of dungeon exploration game (think Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, etc.) or are perhaps caught up in the Dungeon Crawler Carl mania, you might have wondered “Where did this hazardous ruin come from? Why is it here?” Players often go adventuring with little care for backstory—they want treasure—but the behind-the-scenes worldbuilding can be interesting, as In Ruins proves.

In Ruins Basics

The game is for up to six players and takes two or three hours. Your task is to oversee the construction of a fantasy castle, ruin the castle over several centuries, and then populate the castle with various factions of monsters. 

You will need:

            The rule book

            A deck of cards, a few 6-sided dice, and a “first player” token

            Graph paper and regular paper and something to write with (various colors of ink are helpful) or digital journaling device.

Playing In Ruins

The game is aimed at two to four players with modifications for solo play as well as larger group play. The first step is to choose your monster faction, which will be important in the third phase of the game. The faction is essentially your player character, and you might want to steer certain aspects of castle building or destruction in a more favorable direction to your faction. 

The next step is to answer questions about the castle, weaving the backstory of the country, the ruler, and the building. This is the Establishing the Lore stage. As in all cooperative storytelling games, the players bear in the mind the improv maxim to always say, “Yes…and…” rather than contradict each other’s ideas about the castle. This stage can be as minimal or elaborate as your group likes.

Mapping the Castle 

Next, the group takes turns mapping the castle’s construction on graph paper. The limitations are defined by playing cards you hold and spend, with rules for stairs, secret rooms, and the like. In each room you create, you will add a special object. The larger the room, the more “lair points” (which come into play later) it has. Clever play in placement of the rooms will give each player points that can affect the way they build the castle or give advantage in the next stage. 

After the castle is laid out on paper, each player chooses their faction’s future entry point. The points from the building phase can be used to here to access prime locations. 

a hand drawn diagram of a castle room layout

The Castle in Ruins

The next several rounds allow storytelling about why and how this magnificent castle fell to rack and ruin. A theme is set at the start of each round as to what is going wrong for the castle’s ruler, and cards drawn and played describe just how badly the rooms are damaged. And players can make repairs, as well, which might be strategic for their faction’s ultimate takeover of the ruined castle. Players also address the fate of the special objects in the room.

Dungeon Invasion

The final stage of the game is the various factions moving through the ruin, claiming territory and vying against each other for control. Cards are again used to guide the outcomes, which include introducing various hazards, characters, and monsters to rooms as well as using spaces for faction purposes. 

The lair values for each room a faction controls adds up to its final score, and the player with the most points wins. 

My Game Play

Our group had three players and took about two and a half hours. We quickly imagined a steampunkish, stargazing queen in a castle, Rosecrest Hall, surrounded by swamp and fen lands. Aloof from neighboring kingdoms and her own people, a mechanical marvel has elevated her, but an unnatural disaster looms in the future.

Three rounds of castle construction yielded us a dream castle full of cool stuff like a Tesla coil in the workshop, clockwork horses in the stable, and a huge corpse flower in the greenhouse. But we can’t have nice things. An even more advanced tech force attacks her, cutting of the castle from its surrounding. Isolated, the next generations of rulers are frivolous and neglectful of the small folk to the point of peasant uprisings. We ended the tale of the Rosecrest Hall with a bog witch era.

Our three factions, Kobolds, Slimes, and Cultists, quickly burrowed in and loaded the place with traps, cranky orcs, and other hazards. And, of course, the factions are ready to defend their territories against any dungeon crawling invaders that care to come exploring. 

Use the Ruins?

A most intriguing aspect of the game is that you end the game with a dungeon populated with treasure, artifacts, traps and other hazards, and nonplayer characters (NPCs): the starting point of many fantasy adventures. While the group that made the In Ruins dungeon couldn’t really enjoy exploring the ruin, another group would have a grand time with it. Maybe a gamemaster (GM) has two separate groups. Or runs games at conventions. This worldbuilding shouldn’t go to waste!

We had fun with In Ruins, and I recommend it highly.

What makes for an excellent dungeon delve? Comment on the blog.           

If you are interested in In Ruins, you might like to read my review of Microscope, another cooperative worldbuilding game.


green creepy hand crawls across book cover

“The Talking Cure is a marvelous story—an Agatha Christie-style murder mystery infused with a strong sense of the Weird… and a hearty dose of magic on the side. It’s ideal for all fans of the sinister, the surprising, and the strange.”—Cherie Priest, award-winning author of Boneshaker

Find The Talking Cure at these fine locations:

Amazon

Barnes and Noble

Kindle

Kathy L. Brown Bookstore

Left Bank Books in St. Louis

Literary Underworld

Liminal Fiction

And Now a Word from Our Sponsor

Subscribe to the email list for exclusive content and announcements of new books and appearances. And, of course, I’m selling books. Check out all my stories at Amazon.com and my Shop. 

Wolfhearted is also available as an Audible audiobook, here.

Last year, St. Louis Writers Guild published Weird STL, an anthology celebrating the strange, spooky, and just plain wonderful stories of our hometown. This volume of short stories, poems, a play, and essays includes a Sean Joye universe short story, “Big Magick.” Joseph Arwald, one of the baddies from The Big Cinch, tells us what really happened to the Ferris Wheel from the St. Louis 1904 World’s Fair.

Reviews, even a line or two, put the books you enjoyed in a more prominent position on Amazon and are vital for independent and small-press books to find their audience. Remember your most recent read? Leave a review for it on Audible, Amazon, Barnes and Noble, or Goodreads. 

The direct links to post Amazon reviews are: Wolfhearted, here, The Resurrectionist, here, and Water of Life, here. The Big Cinch, here. The Talking Cure, here. Thanks in advance.